All ideas

The Midterm Massacre

A speculative look at the midterm fallout: Trump's political future, Democratic budget policy, and the risk that Tesla and SpaceX emerge as the biggest winners in clean energy and space-based data centers.

We got the direction right. We got the magnitude wrong.

I expected the House to flip and thought the Senate had a real chance of following. The results broadly matched that call, but the scale of the shift surprised me. I had not fully accounted for deep-red states turning blue.

I don’t read this as America suddenly embracing a progressive revolution. Voters can reject the party in power without endorsing the other side’s entire platform. To me, the result was a verdict on a presidency many found exhausting: the war, the Trump family’s conflicts and corruption, the tariffs, and a “Big Beautiful Bill” whose pork failed to win over the mainstream.

A midterm sends a message. It is not always a manifesto.


A wave is not a blank cheque

This result is not a return to the progressive left or its most extreme ideas. Nor is it a mandate for open borders. Voters may simply have wanted less chaos and fewer policies that make daily life feel more expensive or uncertain.

That distinction matters. If Democrats treat the result as permission to pursue an agenda voters did not endorse, they will misread why people moved. Voters can be tired of Trump and still uneasy about the alternatives. Winning a protest vote is easier than earning lasting trust.

The market reaction raises a similar question: what, exactly, is new? The post-election AI selloff is striking when a flipped House was already expected. If the Senate flips too, the immediate difference is largely about confirmations—cabinet officials, judges and other appointments. It would change who can advance through the process, but it would not, with the House already in Democratic hands, make a new legislative agenda any easier to pass. The likely result is still gridlock.

Markets may be reacting to what the result signals about the next two years, or simply taking profits. Election results make headlines, but they do not explain every market move.

A wave can change who holds the microphone without changing what Congress can pass.


Trump has fewer friends and more ways to make noise

Trump’s appointment of Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff does not look to me like an effort to calm the country. It looks like a decision to double down. Miller is a combative figure, and his appointment could bring more confrontation and instability.

I also put the chance of the Secretary of Defense being fired or resigning at 100%. My expectation is that such a departure would bring the war to a halt, though the timing and consequences would depend on what followed.

Republicans will be weighing their own political futures. Some may stay close to Trump; others may decide that the administration’s unpopularity threatens their 2028 prospects. They could distance themselves or challenge his influence to protect their own bids.

One route to removal would be impeachment followed by conviction in the Senate. Impeachment alone would not remove Trump; conviction requires a two-thirds Senate vote, so it would take a substantial break with him by Republicans. Whether that could happen is far from clear.

A more extreme and much less likely scenario would be a coup attempt by Republican insiders to force Trump out outside the constitutional process. That would not be a lawful shortcut or a guaranteed transfer of power; it could trigger a profound constitutional crisis. The vice president and cabinet could also try to invoke the 25th Amendment, but that too would set off a major confrontation rather than a simple or certain transition.

If Trump feels abandoned by allies, his party and his cabinet, I expect more attempts to govern through executive action. Such moves can make headlines quickly, but they also invite legal challenges and reversals. The cycle could become familiar: announce, challenge, block, repeat.


The data-center bind

Another conflict is taking shape. More states have Democratic governors, while local opposition to large AI data centers is growing. Communities have fair questions about electricity, water, land and who pays for the infrastructure. Yet America also wants to stay competitive with China in AI.

The choice is difficult: build more compute on the ground and negotiate the local costs, or look elsewhere. Musk will be watching closely. If data-center construction becomes harder, he could argue for putting compute in space and using SpaceX to get it there. That would be an enormous engineering and economic challenge—not a solution we can assume will work—but the debate could still benefit Musk and SpaceX.

There is an irony here: resistance to data centers could strengthen the case for a Musk-led alternative, even as politicians look for ways to constrain him. Washington can create openings for the very people it is trying to limit.


Elon may find a lane between the parties

The Democrats look leaderless to me and too dependent on lobbyists and wealthy donors. That makes it hard to see how they can direct benefits only to their biggest backers. Policies meant to help many people can also benefit a few powerful companies. Restoring EV or solar credits, for example, could make Tesla one of the most visible winners.

The risk is that Democratic budget policies will only help Tesla dominate clean energy and SpaceX dominate space-based data centers—especially if subsidies and federal contracts reward scale rather than broad competition. Public spending on EVs, batteries, solar and grid storage could reinforce Tesla’s position, while launch and satellite contracts—and any government push toward orbital computing—could strengthen SpaceX. Instead of building a diverse ecosystem, the spending could entrench two Musk companies as gatekeepers.

Musk could emerge as one of the biggest beneficiaries of this moment. If he limits public conflict, distances himself from Trump and chooses his moment, he may find room to build a third party—perhaps with Ye as a high-profile draw. That is speculation, not a report of a plan. But both established parties are leaving space for someone who can attract attention, money and voters who feel unrepresented.

Democrats may underestimate Musk’s ability to shape a story, move quickly and turn a grievance into a political project. Their institutional networks do not guarantee they can outmaneuver him. If they keep treating him as a sideshow, he may gain the advantage.

They could also help him by choosing the wrong response. Investigations seen as politically motivated may energize the party’s base, but they are unlikely to persuade the mainstream. If they look like retaliation rather than accountability, they could hurt Democrats’ 2028 prospects and strengthen Musk’s case for a new political vehicle.


The next collapse may be self-inflicted

Neither party owns the voters who just moved. Democrats could face their own backlash if voters see a lack of integrity, corruption, special-interest politics or an out-of-touch ideology. Those weaknesses could become liabilities, just as the excesses of the MAGA movement have for Republicans.

The pattern is familiar: a party promises to fix what the other broke, then gets comfortable, serves its insiders and mistakes opposition to its rival for support of its own agenda. Eventually, voters notice.

This result should make Democrats cautious, not triumphant. They have an opportunity to govern, focus on ordinary concerns and rebuild trust. If they use their victory only to punish their opponents, they will waste it.


A lose-lose for now

The outlook is uncertain, and meaningful benefits for ordinary Americans are far from guaranteed. Trump may respond to isolation with more executive action. Republicans may split between loyalty and self-preservation. Democrats may mistake rejection of Trump for support of their entire agenda. Musk may see an opening to turn political frustration into a platform of his own.

In that scenario, the country gets more noise and uncertainty, but little that improves daily life. It is a lose-lose, whatever the next round of political messaging promises.

Wall Street could still rally. Markets have climbed walls of worry before, and political drama does not erase earnings, interest rates or investors’ appetite for risk. But a rally would not mean the underlying conflicts had been resolved.

The midterms changed the balance of power; they did not settle the argument. The next two years may be even louder. Whether they bring anything useful remains to be seen.